Budget strobe kit

topic posted Thu, January 11, 2007 - 11:49 AM by  wyoming
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
Ok,
I need some recommendations on 3 head strobe kits that I can purchase for under $1000. I am moving across country in a few months, and will not have access to my free rentals or equipment I"ve been using.

I want a basic portrait strobe kit that is stable and powerful enough for one or two models in the studio. If it's a high wattage assignment on location I'll rent lights.

My problem is I don't know any of the low end strobe heads. Has anyone had any experience with this, or can lead me to some possible sources of information.

I've researched online, but I get alot of the ebay shit that's ridiculously cheap and probably performs just as well. Or I get some strange photo online store that is selling brands I've never heard of with extended warranties. I just don't know what to trust.

I rely on strobes more and more as time goes by, and to move to a new market where I don't have any contacts, I am afraid I will be unable to price rentals into my contracts and still be competitive.

Suggestions?

Thanks in advance

wyoming
posted by:
wyoming
New York City
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Budget strobe kit

    Thu, January 11, 2007 - 3:42 PM
    Depends on wheter or not you expect to grow with the strobe pack.

    www.lensrepro.com/USED/studio.htm

    SPEEDOTRON

    1201A Power pack with 2 102 heads, reflectors $975

    or if you can find a used Dynalite M1000

    here is a head:

    www.bhphotovideo.com/bnh/controller/home

    Profoto Acute 1200 D4-2 kit if you can find it under $1000 it will be a mircle.

    I would consider Elinchrom, or Calumet as well.
    • Re: Budget strobe kit

      Thu, January 11, 2007 - 8:23 PM
      All good suggestions, Speedo, Dynalite, Elinchrom. Since you're shooting fashion, you should consider whether you're going to shoot more in studio or on location, and also what will work better for you, more power/ longer flash duration or less power/shorter flash duration. Of course you can have the best of both, power+speed, but that costs more.
      • Re: Budget strobe kit

        Fri, January 12, 2007 - 12:13 AM
        Ken, it would be mostly portrait and fashion, in studio or home locations. No outdoors. I would rent for those occasions..

        I really like varying power options the most, and independently on the heads. I often like to create ratios, and I get frustrated with power pack modules.
        • Re: Budget strobe kit

          Fri, January 12, 2007 - 9:15 AM
          Ok, then go with Monoblocks of some sort. One of the advantages is that you never have to buy head extension cables, and every time you buy another head, you're buying more power. Disadvantage is that every time you need to adjust power, you need to walk over to each head and do it independently, and if you want to use one on a boom, it has to be seriously have to hold the unit.
    • Re: Budget strobe kit

      Fri, January 12, 2007 - 12:11 AM
      Well I'm not sure about growth, I guess that depends on how reliable and good the strobes i do get end up being :)

      I haven't used dynalites or speedotrons before. But I have used the calumets. I like them, except the modeling lights go out so easily
      • Re: Budget strobe kit

        Fri, January 12, 2007 - 9:21 AM
        Alien Bees. Everyone says, "They're 'pro-sumer, not pro!" but I know more pro photographers who use Alien Bees (either exclusively or in addition to other units) than just about anything else. I use them and LOVE THEM. And their support is the best!! (Sent in a unit out of warranty, they fixed it for free, even replacing the face-plate, which was just scratched.)
        • Re: Budget strobe kit

          Fri, January 12, 2007 - 9:55 AM
          thanks Carl, I'll look up allen Bees and see what they are like.
          • Re: Budget strobe kit

            Fri, January 12, 2007 - 11:35 AM
            What you should know about non-pro brands is how they rate their power (Aka WS, Watt-Seconds). Many second rate manufacturers put a very shiny, well focused mirror-like reflector on their heads before testing, which gives you a false, elevated reading. Why? Because when you take the reflector off to use in a softbox, all that "power" goes away. Also when you use a normal, non-telephoto reflector same thing happens.

            If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. For instance, the Alien Bee B1600 makes you think it puts out 1600Ws, but states that its only 640 "True" WS (they hope you won't notice). This unit runs $359.

            Elinchrom has a 600WS monobloc as well, the 600RX, which sells for $978, so it seems either Elinchrom is gouging you, or Alien Bee is selling junk. And the answer to that is how serious you are about your photography. If you are buying for the future, for best product, for ease of use, for durability, you should go for something like ELinchrom. If you're messing around, or are looking for the cheapest unit you can lay your hands one, get the Alien Bees.

            But first ask yourself some questions. When you went shopping for your digital camera, were you looking for the cheapest? How about your lenses? You want to shoot with the cheapest? And when you get paid for a job, you want to be cheapest there too?
            • Re: Budget strobe kit

              Fri, January 12, 2007 - 1:51 PM
              I second Ken's statement, you get what you pay for...If you are on budget I would go with an older strobe system like Speedotron at least they are American made, they use to be industry standard. If you get a used system at least parts are widely available.

              Profotos are used almost everywhere, all assistants know them inside out, so do most photographers, they are the prefered choice. Alien bees and other less expensive brands are just that, you want the capacitors and flash tubes to always fire consistently from shot to shot.

              You want to invest in a system, where you need those accessories, and those accessories are interchangable with everyone else, I can not think of best choice but get Profoto/Elinchrom/Balcar.
              • Re: Budget strobe kit

                Fri, January 12, 2007 - 6:17 PM
                I agree, if I had the money, I'd be shooting Profotos. I don't have the money. Apparently neither does the original poster or the subject wouldn't be "budget strobe kit". They also expressed a preference for mono-lights as apposed to a pack system. For the money, it's hard to beat Alien Bees. And as for "at least they're American made", last time I checked, Tennessee was in the US. (Has it been de-annexed?)

                Check these sites:
                www.jonsilla.com - all studio shots are with Bees
                www.mitchellkearney.com - most studio shots are Bees
                www.mlobiondo.com - most location shots are Bees

                All are professional commercial photographers who use Bees. How do I know? I've worked with them and they're all friends of mine. I could list a few more as well. And now, I'm not on their level, but all the studio shots at www.carlmillerphotos.photoreflect.com were done with Bees as well.

                Again, I'm not arguing that you can't spend more money and get "better". But for the money, beginners and pros alike are using a lot of Alien Bees. For "junk" they sure seem to make good images with them.
                • Re: Budget strobe kit

                  Fri, January 12, 2007 - 7:34 PM
                  Carl, There are many methods aquiring strobe/studio equipment besides ebay and buying them new.

                  Any large metropolitan city which supports a large advertising industry, will always have used gear in one time or another.

                  Lots of prolabs in NYC, will have people posting their gear for sale, who rather deal with a real person and who would hand over the cash for gear.

                  Rental houses sometimes sell their gear, because they have a certain lifespan. Repair shops will have parts/overstock so are gear coming off of leased programs.

                  Photo studios have a good chance of going bankrupt. I brought my first Speedotron from the Jamesway department store chain when the department store went chapter 11. It was 1200 watt second pack with two heads, $475+$300 for the heads. so it is not entirely impossible to acquire the strobepack within her budget.
  • Re: Budget strobe kit

    Fri, January 12, 2007 - 9:34 PM
    I'd like to chime in and recommend Alien Bees. They are sturdy, well-built (in the US) and reasonably priced. Yes, I agree with the earlier writer who mentioned that the model numbers could be misleading, but they are completely up-front about the specs, so if you want to buy a certain number of watt-seconds, you can easily find out what the model you want provides. They start at $224 and rise to $359. I have two Aliien Bees units, as well as four of the sturdier, more pricey White Lightning strobes (made by the same company, Paul C. Buff in Tennessee). I've thrown them in gear bags, dragged them around to various studios. shot with them outside at the beach and on rooftops. They've functioned flawlessly at all times over a couple of years so far -- and I bought several of the units used! I've known a half-dozen other pros who have used them as long or longer with no complaints. (See www.lorimann.com for one pro who uses them.)

    Yes, there are better, sturdier, better-known and more expensive strobes. Figuring out "what strobe is best" is like asking which is better, Nikon or Canon? You will get people who can argue that for hours, and then some guy will step in and say, "Hasselblad." Of course, he's right, but if you only have the budget for Nikon or Canon, it's irrelevant. If you are a pro or advanced amateur, if you are making money or hoping to make money, but you aren't making big bucks yet, then I highly recommend Alien Bees or White Lightning. I've bought units used on eBay, and Paul C. Buff still gave me tech support and sent me manuals at no charge. Their customer service is legendary. As you read through the forums, you will see lots of pro photographers who bad-mouth these units because of the watt-second question, and indeed, apparently the company did play fast-and-loose with the numbers when they were starting out. But they have cleaned up their act. If you want an idea of how esteemed they've become, check on eBay: Even used ones sell for nearly full retail.

    I am not a shill for Alien Bees. I'm neither dealer nor distributor and I have no affiliation with the company, but the knee-jerk reaction against these units that I see over and over again bewilders me! There are other strobes (like JTL) that are total crap. A friend of mine bought a budget set for some ridiculous price (like $500 for three heads) and after a weekend of shooting, he was already having problems with them like broken knobs and intermittent flashes. Pathetic.

    Cheers,

    David
    • Re: Budget strobe kit

      Sat, January 13, 2007 - 8:49 AM
      I'm not going to back-pedal on this. Look for a major brand and you will not be disappointed. This is not anything like "Canon vs. Nikon". This is like Fiat vs. Toyota. Getting cheap strobes will limit you creativity, the more flexible, powerful, easy to use, rentable your system is, the more likely you are to put out better images.

      Being on a budget does not mean you have to settle for less. It means you have to be patient, and look for the right deal.

      Can you use Alien Bees to shoot? Of course you can. I purchased my first strobe system in 1985, it was old, ratty beat to hell, expensive to repair, expensive accessories for $1000. But it was Balcar. It was light, flexible, powerful, rentable, and built well and very adjustable. Yes it was super-pro gear for a total beginner, but I cut my teeth on strobe with it and started making good images. Years later, when I was done beating on them, and got a Speedo kit, I sold my Balcars for $1000.

      BTW, Mitchell Kinney, I wouldn't use his photos as an example. Most of his portraits are over exposed, or just blasted with light. In addition he can't seem to get a good skin tone, everything bears that orange or pink 'digital' look.
      • Re: Budget strobe kit

        Sat, January 13, 2007 - 11:16 AM
        I agree with Ken not settling for less.

        I brought a used Profoto Acute D2 2400 power back on "Buy It Now" on ebay in Dec 2005 for $995.00, they had four of them for sale.

        I brought a used Profoto Acute D4-2 3000 watt flash head in person Calumet used gear dept last spring 2006 for $275, it was missing a globe & stand base, I talked the saleman down from $375.
        • Re: Budget strobe kit

          Sat, January 13, 2007 - 11:20 AM
          Ken, the late Herb Ritts used older Balcar strobes because there was a surplus of parts for them, he rather use the older packs because he was able to find readily on the open market, and they were less expensive than the state of the art.
  • Re: Budget strobe kit

    Sat, January 13, 2007 - 12:21 PM
    Thanks for all your input you guys.

    I have been watching ebay and looking for good deals on brands I've worked with. The majority is shitty overseas brands for $300. I'll keep an eye out for something better.

    I am looking for monoblocks vs. a powerblock. I use powerblocks, and they're great. But for some reason, I find I get best results for creative projects with those monoblocks.

    I like profoto. I"ve used profoto and calumet and norman and white lighting. I think they are all good. What I don't like is that I can't afford it.

    My reservations about buying online is that it is really sight unseen, and untested. SO I have to have faith that the online store is honest about any flaws, etc. in used gear.

    One benefit that I did see on the alien bee site is the 2 yr warranty...

    no used pro foto is gonna offer that. ;)
    • Re: Budget strobe kit

      Sat, January 13, 2007 - 12:51 PM
      Wyoming I use to be in the used photo gear retail business. If you can buy anything 50% off of retail new as long as it is being made then you are ahead. Figure 20% risk for repair an that is acceptable. Most people sell items on ebay close to 80% retail value. So all depends on your usage.

      If you can't afford lights, a Scrim/Overhead in natural lights with Reflectors are the least expensive method. Who said this profession was cheap? If one is a pro and making money, any capital expense can be used against income, while I am not an accountant, I suggest one seek professional advice in this matter.
  • Re: Budget strobe kit

    Tue, January 16, 2007 - 7:51 PM
    Wy,

    I and a good friend of mine both have the Alien Bees different power outputs. Never had a problem in 3+ years. They have a 60 day return policy too, so if you hate them or they don't work like you want them to, send them back. They are made by the same company that makes White Lightning, as someone previously mentioned. If price is an issue, I would not count them out. Consider that modifiers will cost more as well on the Elinchrome, Profoto kits.

    Just my thoughts.
    • Re: Budget strobe kit

      Tue, January 16, 2007 - 9:49 PM
      thanks Lynn. I'm more and more impressed with reviews I get of them. They're pro-sumer for sure, but that's what I am at the current time. :)

      and I rather like hot pink
      • Re: Budget strobe kit

        Wed, January 24, 2007 - 11:04 AM
        bwahahah Fiat VS Toyota !! Ken you rock !! I can't add anything that Ken hasn't said but man FIAT VS Toyota that is too good to pass. I know this is off topic but you know that FIAT stands for Fix It Again Tony !! I lived in Italy and yes I owned a Fiat and oooooohh the pain it gave me. Spend the money on good lights if you can't afford 3 good heads buy 2 and use a mirroe or reflector it can be done if you are creative enough with your lighting !
  • Re: Budget strobe kit

    Thu, June 21, 2007 - 1:27 AM
    ok ok, it takes me a long time to make a decision - but finally I did. after 6 months' of pricing, watching auctions, trying new power packs, strobes etc - I did go with the alien bees.

    Mostly for bang for the buck and for versatility. this was the only pro-sumer brand with a 2 year warranty that could get me 5 flashes and portable battery power for all five, with accessories.

    I know I may have sacrificed some power per head, but I think intitially I'll be happy with what they output.

    I also just got a new nikor 70-200 VR lens and D200. So I'll test it all and tell y'all what I results I get. :)

    thank you for your many fine opinions!
    • Re: Budget strobe kit

      Thu, June 21, 2007 - 6:22 PM
      I am stoked to read this. Now, go and join the Paul C. Buff forums at www.paulcbuff.com/forums/

      It's the only forum I'm aware of in which the owner of the company regularly stops by to answer questions, encourage photographers, and just hang out.

      Just beware: It is addictive. You may end up buying a ring light if you aren't careful!

      Good luck with your new setup!

      David
    • ra
      ra
      offline 25

      Re: Budget strobe kit

      Thu, June 21, 2007 - 8:53 PM
      I use Alien Bees. They've been working for many years with nothing more than bulb replacement. One very busy day one of them started smoking. I turned it off before it flamed out. After it cooled off I turned it back on and it still works fine. Pretty amazing.
      • Re: Budget strobe kit

        Thu, June 21, 2007 - 11:45 PM
        I can't wait to try them out. They do get good reviews from people who are using them. The clincher for me was studio powered and battery power together.

Recent topics in "Pro Photographers"